Thursday, December 8, 2011

Ship Breaker

* Image from escapepod.org
A. Bibliographic Data: Bacigalupi, Paolo. Ship Breaker. New York: Little Brown and Co., 2010. ISBN 9780316056212

B. Plot Summary: Nailer is a young boy forced to venture into the unknown depths of the ocean daily in search of copper wire; with his small frame and fierce determination he has managed to not only make a name for himself but to prove his worth among a sometimes skeptical and dangerous work crew. After a scary near death experience and just when luck seems to finally be shining on him, Nailer stumbles upon a discovery that for better or worse, leads to one of the hardest decisions he’ll ever have to make. Will Nailer choose to strip the newfound ship for all its worth or will he choose to save the sole survivor of the ship- a beautiful young girl and trust in her promise to lead him to a better life? In his debut young adult novel, Paolo Bacigalupi takes readers on an adventure full of life-changing choices, greed, heartbreak and strength.

C. Critical Analysis: Characters: The complexities of Nailer and his family may seem as though it would make it difficult for readers to relate to him but in fact, it does the opposite! Readers will be immediately drawn to Nailer and his many layers. Readers will also undoubtedly be concerned with what happens to Nailer and how his decisions will affect him and the other characters in the novel. Nailer’s presence in this novel is absolutely critical to the story as a whole and although the plot is highly interesting and innovative, Nailer’s personal journey and emotional growth is what truly guides readers to finish the book. The language of the book, as well as the dialogue, is fresh, natural and accurately represents young adults.

Plot: The plot of the story is highly creative and will be something completely new to most (if not all) readers. The sequence of events are logical and consistent, providing readers with a great foundation to make their own personal connections. Little moralizing is done and readers will finish the novel with a definite feeling of hope and optimism. The story gives most attention to Nailer-his relationships and growth versus there being an actual quest he has to complete. The villain is not a big scary monster, but instead overcoming oneself to stand up for what you believe in, to be loyal when it’s entirely too hard to be, and to trust your instincts and learn to let people in.

Setting: The details of the setting are highly vivid and equally integral to the story itself. With Bacigalupi’s words, readers will be more than capable of clearly visualizing the oceans surrounding Nailer, the ships that he spends so much of his time in, and the heavily polluted beaches. I also particularly enjoyed reading about the descriptions of the people in the story with their tattoos and distinct features. Though this novel is set in the future, readers will be able to recognize similarities between that society and ours today. The setting is believable (because it is based on events of today- like diminishing natural resources and global warming) and will be applicable to many different situations in the past, present, and future.

Theme: There is a heavy emphasis placed on loyalty and its importance among friends. Also, knowing and acting upon the difference between right and wrong is present throughout Nailer’s voyage. The hope and contentment Nailer feels at the conclusion of the book will also leave readers feeling satisfied and content themselves. The themes are naturally presented and readers will be able to follow Nailer’s actions from childhood to adulthood.

Style: There is a consistent balance between narration and dialogue that increases readers ability to fully understand everything going on in Nailer’s world. The dialogue feels very natural and although this story is set in the future, readers will be able to relate to the camaraderie that exists between characters. The point of view is highly appropriate and consistent allowing plenty of room for readers to fully understand all aspects of the text.  

D. Awards/Recognition and Review Excerpts: Andre Norton Award Nominee 2010, Cybil Award Finalist 2010, Green Earth Book Award Honor Book 2011, Michael L. Printz Award Winner 2011, National Book Award Finalist Young People's Literature 2010
Amazon Editors' Picks: Top 10 Books 2010, Best Children's Books of the Year 2011, Booklist Top 10 Books on the Environment for Youth 2011, Booklist Top 10 SF/Fantasy for Youth 2011, Choices 2011, Notable Children's Books 2011, Publishers Weekly Best Children's Books 2010, Publishers Weekly Book Review Stars 2010, VOYA Top Shelf Fiction for Middle School Readers 2010, Washington Post Best Kid's Books, 2010, YALSA Best Fiction for Young Adults 2011, YALSA Top Ten Best Fiction for Young Adults, 2011
“Clearly respecting his audience, Bacigalupi skillfully integrates his world building into the compelling narrative, threading the backstory into the pulsing action. The characters are layered and complex, and their almost unthinkable actions and choices seem totally credible. Vivid, brutal, and thematically rich, this captivating title is sure to win teen fans…”- Lynn Rutan, Booklist 2010
“In a tale of love, trust and coming-of-age, this book will keep you on the edge of your seat wondering who can be trusted and how Nailer will get out of his next life-threatening situation. I would recommend this book to young adults and adults alike.” – Lindsey Riegner, Kutztown University Book Review

E. Connections: *This is the first young adult novel written by Paolo Bacigalupi. His first adult novel is titled The Windup Girl. Other work of his can be found in High Country News, Salon.com, The Magazine of Fantasy and Science Fiction, and Asimov’s Science Fiction Magazine.
* Use this novel as a complement to instruction on the importance of recycling, preserving Earth’s natural resources, global warming, and the effects of pollution.

Lunch Lady and the Summer Camp Shakedown

*Image from comicsworthreading.com

A. Bibliographic Data: Krosoczka, Jarrett J. Lunch Lady and the Summer Camp Shakedown. New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 2010. ISBN 9780375960956

B. Plot Summary: In this wacky, silly and slightly strange (in the totally awesome way) graphic novel, the school lunch lady finds herself as the main cook at summer camp. Lucky for her the breakfast bunch kids: Dee, Hector, and Terrance help her once again in her highly dangerous, overly intense investigation of the swamp monster mystery. This action-packed graphic novel is sure to capture the attention of readers both young and old, and is sure to become an instant favorite among students. So pack your bags readers, we’re going to summer camp!  

C. Critical Analysis: Characters: Even though this is a fantasy novel, the characters are A. human, B. highly relatable and C. easy to love! Readers will immediately be drawn into the storyline and dive even deeper into the story by imagining their own lunch lady as a crime-fighting, mystery-solving protagonist. Lunch ladies are pretty familiar among school students, and having one as the main character makes this novel familiar and comfortable. The other characters, or members of the breakfast bunch kids, also provide readers with an outlet for connections while being engaged with the text. Being a part of a series also ensures that readers will care about what happens to the characters and look forward to future adventures.

Plot: Since many students attend summer camp themselves, the plot has the potential to really hit home. The sequence of events is logical while still managing to fit in some exciting twist and turns. Krosoczka does a wonderful job of presenting his creativity in a way that doesn’t take away from the plot but makes it more interesting instead. In this novel, the lunch lady and the breakfast bunch kids have the task of unraveling the mystery of the swamp monster. This can be viewed as not only a journey but as vanquishing a villain as well. Though in the end the monster isn’t exactly what the campers initially had in mind, the mystery is put to rest nonetheless. Readers will find the conclusion to be both satisfying and understandable.

Setting: Because readers are depending solely on dialogue and pictures, I would say the details of the setting are not explicitly given to readers. I would also not describe the setting as an integral part of the story. Readers are able to gather information about the setting through pictures, but very little through the actual words of the novel. Though this is a fantasy novel, the setting is not fantastical. A summer camp with cabins and a lake would seem pretty common to readers. Instead the element of fantasy comes from the swamp monster himself versus the setting. Details are not vivid and aside from the pictures would not be given at all.

Theme: In the end, the mystery is solved and there’s no such swamp monster plaguing the summer camp. There’s a happy ending and though readers will find this ending to be satisfying, it is hard to pick out an obvious universal theme in this graphic novel. Instead is seems to be more of a purely enjoyable read, with an emphasis on humor and action; though in the end the bad (the swamp monster) does get defeated by good (the lunch lady and the breakfast bunch kids). Though there isn’t a great moral theme to get out of reading this novel, students will still enjoy reading it and will be a great series to use as an introduction into the world of graphic novels.

Style: Because readers are continually seeing who is speaking and when, they are able to distinguish the distinct language of each character. This language is consistent with typical kids in the characters’ age group and would seem natural in a similar setting in actual life. Though I am not overly familiar with Krosoczka’s work, I would venture to say that his humor provides a great foundation for the story, characters, plot and even setting. The point of view throughout the whole novel is the same, and is great for allowing students to decipher between characters and keep up with the flow of the story. Because the setting and plot are so highly believable I do not think this novel encourages readers to think inside the fantasy world.

D. Awards/Recognition and Review Excerpts: Children’s Choice Book Award Winner Grades 3-4, 2011
“Krosoczka’s inventive visual details, spot-on characterizations, and grade-school humor make this a standout graphic-novel series.”- Francisca Goldsmith, Booklist
“Somewhat reminiscent of old “Scooby Doo” cartoons, Lunch Lady and the Summer Camp Shakedown spotlights a goofy plot full of Krosoczka’s usual cafeteria-themed superhero gear. Younger kids with an appreciation for silliness will love it.” – Michael Jung, Children’s Literature

E. Connections: *Other graphic novels in the Lunch Lady series written by Jarret J. Krosoczka include: Lunch Lady and the Cyborg Substitute (1), Lunch Lady and the League of Librarians (2), Lunch Lady and the Author Visit Vendetta (3), Lunch Lady and the Bake Sale Bandit (5), and Lunch Lady and the Field Trip Fiasco (6).
* Because graphic novels are growing in popularity among children and young adults, what better way to have students share their own stories through this unique format?! Have students create their own shorter graphic novel or full-length novel (over the course of the year) in which they share their own silliest, wackiest adventure of the school year!
* Use this as an introduction to graphic novels. Students will love the completely fictional plot, and will become engaged in the non-traditional way of storytelling. This will encourage students to read more, make connections with what they’re reading and become engaged with literature.     

Tuesday, December 6, 2011

Joey Pigza Loses Control

*Image from tower.com
A. Bibliographic Data: Gantos, Jack. Joey Pigza Loses Control. New York: Douglas & McIntyre Ltd., 2000. ISBN 0374399891

B. Plot Summary: Despite his Mother’s strong hesitations, Joey Pigza is spending his summer vacation with his ever elusive Father Carter. With hopes of creating a life-long relationship full of all the classic father-son activities, Joey is approaching the summer with high hopes and higher expectations. What he gets though, isn’t exactly what he had in mind. In this second book of the Joey Pigza series, Joey finds out about losing control the hard way. Lessons on the effects of addiction, the anger of alcoholism and the heartbreak of loving someone before they’re ready to help themselves overcomes Joey’s summer and leaves him in a pretty sticky situation. Though the summer ends abruptly for Joey and readers, the message of this story is guaranteed to last a lifetime.     

C. Critical Analysis: Characters: With this story, Joey has to deal with some serious issues! Alcoholism, addiction, anger, and tough love (on top of being medicated for ADHD and taking special education classes at school) are among the issues that take Joey on a tough and long emotional journey. As the actual plot can be seen in any other book- it is this journey and growth that makes Joey stand out so much and makes this story so highly relatable. Though the narration is an important aspect of this novel, the dialogue gives readers great insight into Joey’s world. Through the back and forth between Joey and his mother, father, and grandmother readers are able to see the complexities of his emotions. The language of this book is very believable and captures the essence of young adults everywhere. All readers, regardless of age, ethnicity or gender will find Joey’s highly critical character both refreshing and relatable-making it a must-read for everyone!

Plot: With divorce rates higher than ever, readers will find the plot of this story very believable and true to life. Many students will be in the same boat of never having met their father/mother so the feelings of meeting the parent for the first time will immediately by familiar to them. Readers will feel engaged with Joey and will be looking to keep reading to see what happens next! The twists and turns of the plot are exciting while maintaining likelihood and not stretching the reader’s belief too far. The end of the story doesn’t thrive on a happy ending, but one of hope nonetheless. Readers will enjoy seeing Joey leave a sticky situation but will hope that Joey’s father can find his way out too, though it’s left up to the reader’s discretion. Because there is no typical happy ending Gantos has managed to create a story that avoids coincidence and an overly moralizing tone. Instead readers are left with a fresh plot, that may start out like any other parent visitation summer story- but definitely has its own complexities and morals that make it completely its own.  

Setting: The setting of the story is very believable and sets readers in a time very much like present day. Readers of the past ten years would be able to relate as well as those readers to come in the next ten years. Gantos does a great job of bringing the essence of Joey’s surroundings without excluding the possibility of them taking place in any old place. Details as well as generalizations are used, making it possible for readers to find similarities between this story’s setting and their own surroundings. This makes the plot and other story elements that much more obvious and does not take away from the message given. Instead, the setting is the perfect complement to Joey’s summer with his dad.  

Theme: There are many highly important themes addressed within this novel. Joey is continually asked to decide for himself the difference between right and wrong (even when that means going against an adult when adults are always thought to be right), to grant acceptance (even though it’s not always deserved), to overcome self-doubt, and to find the strength to stand up for oneself, get help and get out. These themes definitely show evidence of traveling into adulthood while still creating connections with young readers. These themes are given to readers without moralizing and the feeling of being forced upon readers. Readers are able to read the novel, receive the messages and apply them to their own life as fit in the natural way.  

Style: Though this is the first novel by Jack Gantos I have read, his writing style immediately stuck out to me. The naturalness captured through dialogue made reading the book easy and continual. Insert wit, some sprinkles of sarcasm, and a quirky sense of humor and you have Jack Gantos’ writing style (or at least my own interpretation of it). As mentioned before, the narration of the novel also plays a pivotal role in the completion of this novel. Because Joey is the narrator we are given even more insight into his world, the complexities of his feelings and how his brain works. All of this adds to the reader’s ability to relation and make meaningful connections to the message. Overall the book is well organized and seems to do a great job of successfully representing Jack Gantos.

Gender and Culture: The protagonist in this novel is male- Joey Pigza. He is not stereotyped or typecasted in either a negative or positive way. He also represents real people and their real problems in a way that would be highly effective for both young and old readers. Culture doesn’t play a large role in this book, though the idea of culture can be gathered through dialogue, situations and responses to those situations. Needless to say, cultural details do not overload the story but is accurately presented when done.   

D. Awards/Recognition and Review Excerpts: John Newbery Medal Honor Book 2001, Maine Student Book Award 2002, Parents' Choice Award 2000 Gold, Parents' Choice Award 2003 Gold, Best 25 Books in 25 Years, White Ravens Award Winner 2001
Adventuring with Books: A Booklist for PreK-Grade 6, 13th Edition, 2002, Best Children's Books of the Year 2001, Booklist Book Review Stars, Sep. 1, 2000, Booklist Editors' Choice: Books for Youth 2000, Bulletin Blue Ribbons 2000, Bulletin of the Center for Children's Books, Children's Literature Choice List 2001, Horn Book Fanfare 2000, Kirkus Book Review Stars June 15 2000, Middle And Junior High School Library Catalog Supplement to the Eighth Edition 2001, Notable Children's Books 2001, Recommended Literature: Kindergarten through Grade Twelve 2002, School Library Journal Best Books 2000, School Library Journal Book Review Stars, September 2000, VOYA Top Shelf Fiction for Middle School Readers 2000
“… [Gantos] has written a dead-on portrayal of a young person assessing the often self-serving behavior of the adults who control his life. Few children these days don't know someone wrestling with ADHD; meeting up with Joey is a fine way to gain insight into the problems "hyper" children face. But the story is more than message. Ganto's skillful pacing, sly humor, and in-depth characterization make it a truly memorable read.”- Susan Dove Lempke, Booklist 2000
“Gantos brilliantly portrays the often-manic pace of an ADHD mind, but he alleviates the tension with touches of humor… Joey is a young teen struggling to maintain control in an often out-of-control world, a struggle with which many teens will relate. Gantos's style of writing and the subject matter make this book a great middle school read-aloud.”- Ruth Cox, VOYA 2001

E. Connections: *Joey Pigza Loses Control  is the second book in the Joey Pigza series written by Jack Gantos. Other titles in the series include: Joey Pigza Swallowed the Key (book 1), What Would Joey Pigza Do? (book 3), and I am not Joey Pigza (book 4)
*Have students act out chapter(s) of this book in Readers Theater. This will be a great way to engage students and get them excited about reading this story!
*Have students reflect on their own personal experiences with losing control and the different emotions that took over. Students can present their experiences through poetry, short stories, narratives or comic strips. 

Thursday, November 17, 2011

The Evolution of Calpurnia Tate

*Image from indiebound.org

A. Bibliographic Data: Kelly, Jacqueline. The Evolution of Calpurnia Tate. New York: Henry Holt and Company, 2009. ISBN 9780805088410

B. Plot Summary: As Calpurnia Tate can tell you firsthand, there’s a lot to learn when you’re eleven years old. In reading this book, readers will grow right along with Calpurnia (Callie) Tate as she beats the 1899 Texas heat by spending time with nature (and her beloved Grandfather), learning the meaning of unconditional love, finding her own place in her family, and discovering the joys (and many struggles) of being a girl. Jacqueline Kelly is able to illustrate the many discoveries one can find during a lifetime and does so in a historical setting bound to take readers back to a time when things were thought to be simpler. As Callie struggles to balance her love of science with pleasing her Momma (even if that means learning to sew, cook, and clean), she takes us all on a coming of age, turn of the century voyage sure to entertain and educate at the same time.

C. Critical Analysis: Characters: Calpurnia Tate, being the main character, is highly relatable and identifiable to readers. Although the story takes place many years before present-day, readers will be able to relate and understand the complexity of the emotions and feelings Calpurnia encompasses. Boys too can relate to Callie’s struggle to meet expectations, control her strong will, and guide curiosity. I also feel that Calpurnia is very believable- many of the conflicts she meets and resolves are very much alive and present in the lives of students today. Aside from the raw emotion presented in this book, the clothes, dialogue, language and attitudes all reflect and support the late 1800’s era. Examples of this would be in how Callie is asked to wear a bonnet when she’s outside so she won’t get freckles, and referring to a person as a “whip”- a term that would be unfamiliar to students today.

Plot: I feel that the plot of this story is realistic to the time period and that the history is presented accurately versus being sugar coated. Like for women during the 1800’s was hard, and most were expected to manage domestic affairs. Education and science were saved for men, and women were limited in what they could accomplish outside of the home. Because of this, the conflicts and resolutions of this book are very fitting and historically sound. I feel that the typical reader of this book would be between grades 5 and 8. Though the main character is eleven, the complexities of her emotions would seem relevant for older readers as well. Younger readers could understand the novel with the periodic help of a dictionary. I don’t at all feel that the plot is overwhelmed by details, but is presented in a simplistic yet multi-layered manner.

Setting: Jacqueline Kelly does a wonderful job at vividly describing the place in which this story takes place. Through her words, readers are able to picture the Texas nature that steals so much of Callie’s attention. The actual time is not explicitly given, though readers are able to draw conclusions based on Kelly’s descriptions of people and society. Texas has four different physical regions that would be ideal for science explorations and different species of grasshoppers. That being said, I do  feel Texas was a great choice for the setting of this book, but do think Kelly could have chosen a different state and been just as successful. I do feel that the recreation done by Kelly fully supports the overall authenticity the book hopes to accomplish.

Theme: Such themes as unconditional love, acceptance, curiosity, freedom and finding one’s self are all apparent in The Evolution of Calpurnia Tate. Though these themes are directly related to the era of the novel, I feel that they would still be relevant to readers today. Everyone has a coming of age moment, and people spend their entire lives searching for unconditional love-with this novel we see the journey of both. I would also describe those themes as universal and timeless, making them likely to remain relevant in the years to come.

Style: The speech patterns and flavor of the time is very well represented through Kelly’s style of writing. She manages to place readers back in time by the way the characters interact with each other, describe occurrences, and responds to situations. This novel is completely seamless and gives the reader a great, easy-flowing novel to read. Because this is Jacqueline Kelly’s first novel, critics have little to compare her personal style to. I can say though that I look forward to reading her future novels and becoming more familiar with her personal writing style.  

Additional Criteria: I was a little disappointed to read that Kelly “for the sake of fiction, [has] taken small liberties with Texas history” in her acknowledgement pages located directly after the novel. She further explains “also for the sake of fiction, I have taken liberties with the blooming season of certain plants and the taxonomy of the Vicia genus.” She then apologizes for doing so and continues to acknowledge the various sources she researched to help create her story. By labeling this story as historical fiction, it is scary to see that the author admittedly changes some of the facts to help the fictional story. This tells me that there is not a balance between fact and fiction but that fiction weighs heavier. There was no stereotyping done.


E. Connections: * Have students compare and contrast life in Texas during the 1800’s and now. Students can use a T-chart, ven diagram, or web. Begin and end with a class discussion.
* Read this novel as an extension of the importance of exploration. Where would we be if scientists never explore? What do you think would happen if people stop being curious? How would this affect us?
* Have students reflect through short stories or plays a time when they were expected to do/be something they didn’t quite agree with. How did they situation play out? How did you feel? How did you decide what to do?

Wednesday, November 16, 2011

One Crazy Summer

*Image from ritawg.com

A. Bibliographic Data: Garcia-Williams, Rita. One Crazy Summer. New York: HarperCollins Publishers, 2010. ISBN 9780060760885

B. Plot Summary: Eleven year old Delphine and her two younger sisters-Vonetta and Fern are forced to visit their ever elusive and absent mother Cecile in California for the summer of 1968. Aside from the immediate rejection they receive from their mother upon arrival, the girls manage to learn about themselves, the complexity of the world they live in, and what it means to be an African American during this time period. In this telling book, Rita Garcia-Williams gives readers a unique and intricate look into the Black Panthers and the civil rights movement. The recollection of this one crazy summer will touch all readers with a sense of where we’ve been as a nation, and the distance we have left to go.  

C. Critical Analysis: Characters: There are four main characters in this book with various minor characters to additionally support the plot of the story. I feel Delphine and her two younger sisters would be highly relatable to readers in the past while maintaining their relevancy to today’s readers as well. Though certain aspects such as the T.V. shows being watched, the music listened to and the clothes worn, would be different if the story was set in today’s time, readers will still be able to see themselves in the feelings and emotions the sisters portray. Delphine, Vonetta and Fern possess a believability that will reach all readers, making them instantly liked and enjoyed.    

Plot: The one aspect I found so appealing about this story is that it was so realistic to the time period in which it took place. Though I personally didn’t live through the sixties, I found myself clearly picturing them through this book. The dialect of Delphine and her sisters, the characteristics of the Black Panthers and the experiences the sisters were facing, did a great job of bringing this time period to life for readers. The plot has a great story-like feel, though this is considered a historical piece, readers are not overwhelmed with details and facts. Instead, readers are given the essence of the time period and movement-allowing room for personal interpretation and connections. I do feel that this novel would be ideal for readers between grades four and six though younger readers may be able to get some of the novel’s message if not all.  

Setting: The time period of this novel is explicitly given to readers. We immediately know the story is taking place in the summer of 1968 in Oakland, California. Through Garcia-William’s figurative language readers are then given a complete and thorough description of the time and place. Because the Black Panthers were founded in Oakland, California I strongly believe the setting plays an integral part of the story as a whole. By taking place in the heart of the Black Panther movement, Garcia-Williams is able to immediately accomplish a level of authenticity with readers. This shows readers that although this is a highly entertaining novel, it also contains historical information.

Theme: Though this is a novel primarily enveloping the civil rights movement and the Black Panthers, a movement directly related to the novel’s late nineteen sixties time period, its other themes and morals can still be applied to society today. Underlying themes such as love, acceptance and open-mindedness are ideas that readers of the past, present and future will all encounter during their lives. A dysfunctional family life can also be found across time periods. I feel that all themes found in this novel can be described as both universal and timeless.

Style: I think this novel does a wonderful job of reflecting Rita Garcia-Williams’ voice and manner. Through her word choice and language readers are given a glimpse of the Black Panthers as Garcia-Williams would see it. Her words created pictures for readers to rely on, and it is her words that brought the sisters to life. Aside from that, the flavor and speech patterns of the time were fully captured through Delphine’s dialect. Readers get a clear idea of what people would sound like during this time period. As mentioned before, this novel has a high story-like feel to it. The fact that it is taking place in history adds to the novel overall instead of taking away from it. Readers will not feel as though they are reading about history, but instead will feel that they are reading a complete novel that could take place during any time period.

Additional Criteria: At the end of this novel, Garcia-Williams includes an acknowledgements section for readers’ benefit. It is here Garcia-Williams thanks those that helped her create this book, but also gives the articles, books and magazines she referenced to complete the story. It is with this that the book accomplishes a sense of authenticity and realness. I would have to say that this novel contains more fiction that fact. The three sisters are purely fictional and although they are experiencing historical events, the recollection is all fiction. Overall I feel that the novel lacks stereotyping and would be a great read for students looking to learn a little more about the civil rights movement in an entertaining way.

“Set during a pivotal moment in African American history, this vibrant novel shows the subtle ways that political movements affect personal lives; but just as memorable is the finely drawn, universal story of children reclaiming a reluctant parent’s love.”- Gillian Engberg, Booklist 2010
“On a broader level, it gives a unique perspective of a part of history not often seen in youth literature. The Black Panther aspect is thought-provoking, adding depth to the theme of Delphine’s family situation. Aside from the plot, the natural writing makes this a smooth read from start to finish, and the characters and situations are realistic. It’s a “must” for library collections.”- Cherie Ilg Haas, Children’s Literature

E. Connections: *Other works by Rita Williams-Garcia include: Jumped, No Laughter Here, Every Time a Rainbow Dies, Catching the Wild Waiyuuzee, Like Sisters on the Homefront, Fast Talk on a Slow Track, and Blue Tights
* Have students reflect on a crazy summer of their own through poetry, short stories, comic strips, essays or plays
*Use this novel to support and further explore the civil rights movement through class discussions, KWL charts, and character analysis

Monday, November 14, 2011

Hiroshima: A Novella

* Image from amazon.com

A. Bibliographic Data: Yep, Laurence. Hiroshima. New York: Scholastic Inc., 1995. ISBN 0590208322

B. Plot Summary: With this direct and factual book, readers are taken back to 1945 when the atomic bomb drops and forever changes Hiroshima, Japan. Laurence Yep covers many different aspects of the bombing including information on the planes that flew that day, the city of Hiroshima and a complete recollection of the events of that terrible August day. Yep successfully recreates the essence of the Japanese people so deeply affected by the bombing through his two main characters- Sachi and Riko. By the end of this book, readers will have an understanding of the ramifications one decision can have on humanity, our planet and the future.

C. Critical Analysis: Characters: There are three characters used in this short novella; Sachi, Riko and Colonel Tibbets. Sachi and Riko are Japanese sisters that were directly affected by the bombing. Through their presence, readers are able to put themselves in the shoes of those living in Hiroshima during the bombing and are immediately able to relate. Readers will be able to identify with the sisters while recognizing the deep Japanese traditions they encompass. Colonel Tibbets is the American pilot responsible for flying the B-29 and dropping the atomic bomb. Though he has a minimal role, readers will still benefit from his input. By providing at least one character on each side, Yep allows room for class discussion. All three characters are highly believable and will be easily understood by all readers.

Plot: Overall, the history of this book is very factual and lacks any kind of sugar coating. Readers are presented with mainly facts, sprinkled periodically with Yep’s gift of language in the form of metaphors or similes. Short, concise sentences are used making the novella easy for students to understand. The choppiness of the sentences also eliminates all possibilities of being overwhelmed with details, excess information and unnecessary opinions. Yep did a wonderful job of presenting his story in a way this is relevant to the time period in which this horrific event happened, while maintaining a relevancy that not only stands in present day, but will continue to reach readers in the years to come.

Setting: The setting of this story definitely complements the historical authenticity of the story overall. With Yep’s words, readers are taken back to Hiroshima through mental images created with the details given. Readers are able to create their own ideas of what Hiroshima was like before, during and after the bombing, what it was like inside the plane with the American pilots, and how the Japanese people are still moved by the events of August 6th 1945 today. The time and place are explicitly given to readers through dates.

Theme: The most obvious universal theme and timeless parallels found in this novella would be that war is never the answer. By bringing to light all the personal travesties that occur when countries choose to war with each other and continue to kill their citizens, Yep is enforcing that as humans we should always choose peace over war. This will continue to remain relevant for many years to come.  

Style: Yep’s words are limited in number and very direct. Though I am not familiar with much of Yep’s other works I would conclude that this type of writing is conclusive with his personal style and voice. I don’t see much evidence to support that the diction reflects the 1940’s in any way, nor can any connections be made between Yep’s diction and ‘capturing the flavor of the times’. I think the sentences are too compact and direct to make any such observations. Though this story of Hiroshima is entertaining and informational to readers, I wouldn’t describe it as seamless. There is a lot of bouncing back and forth between time periods, characters and setting. The story eventually comes full circle, but does so in a choppy, different kind of way. Realistically, the story could take place in any time period; aside from the dates given, the reader would not explicitly know which time period Yep is referring to.

Additional Criteria: To support authenticity, Yep includes an Afterword for readers to read and a list of sources used to compile his story. This shows readers that Yep spent a significant amount of time researching before writing, and readers can trust his facts to be accurate and true. With the ample facts given, Yep provides a nice balance of fiction by incorporating the two sisters into the historically correct bombing of Hiroshima. Yep’s creation of the sisters is fully explained in the Afterword and readers are given reasons and ideas the characters stemmed from. There is no evidence of stereotyping taking place within this novella.

D. Awards/Recognition and Review Excerpts: Adventuring with Books: A Booklist for PreK-Grade 6, 1997, Booklist Book Review Starts, 1995, Booklist Editors’ Choice: Books for Youth, 1995, Children’s Catalog Eighteenth Edition, 2001, Kaleidoscope: A Multicultural Booklist for Grades K-8 Second Ed. 1997, Middle and Junior High School Library Catalog: Eighth Ed., 2000, Notable Children’s Trade Books in the Field of Social Studies, 1995, Publisher’s Weekly Book Review Stars, 1995, and Sharing Cultures: Asian American Children’s Authors, 2001.
“Yep's clipped, present-tense writing resists editorializing, letting the terrible facts speak for themselves ("Two hundred yards away [from ground zero] people vanish. However, in that instant, their outlines are burnt into the cement like shadows")… this is easy reading-as far as language and sentence structure go-and kids not ready for more comprehensive accounts can here gain a clear and fair introduction to a epoch-defining event.”- Roger Sutton, The Bulletin of the Center for Children’s Books, 1995.
“The account is fair, non-hectoring, and totally devastating. Though accessible to middle-grade readers, this will also interest older readers, who will find nothing condescending in content or format.”- Hazel Rochman, Booklist, 1995.

E. Connections: *Other works by Laurence Yep include: Child of the Owl, Dragon of the Lost Sea, Dragon’s Gate, The Rainbow People, The Dragon Prince, The Lost Garden, The Tiger’s Apprentice, The Magic Paintbrush, The Serpent’s Children, and The Traitor.
*Use this novella to support social studies instruction, activities, and discussions on World War II.
*Have students research the museum dedicated to remembering the lives lost by the dropping of the atomic bomb. Introduce students to the Paper Crane Club and suggest sending in our own paper cranes to be hung on the anniversary of the bombing.