* Image from amazon.com
A. Bibliographic Data: Yep, Laurence. Hiroshima. New York: Scholastic Inc., 1995. ISBN 0590208322
B. Plot Summary: With this direct and factual book, readers are taken back to 1945 when the atomic bomb drops and forever changes Hiroshima, Japan. Laurence Yep covers many different aspects of the bombing including information on the planes that flew that day, the city of Hiroshima and a complete recollection of the events of that terrible August day. Yep successfully recreates the essence of the Japanese people so deeply affected by the bombing through his two main characters- Sachi and Riko. By the end of this book, readers will have an understanding of the ramifications one decision can have on humanity, our planet and the future.
C. Critical Analysis: Characters: There are three characters used in this short novella; Sachi, Riko and Colonel Tibbets. Sachi and Riko are Japanese sisters that were directly affected by the bombing. Through their presence, readers are able to put themselves in the shoes of those living in Hiroshima during the bombing and are immediately able to relate. Readers will be able to identify with the sisters while recognizing the deep Japanese traditions they encompass. Colonel Tibbets is the American pilot responsible for flying the B-29 and dropping the atomic bomb. Though he has a minimal role, readers will still benefit from his input. By providing at least one character on each side, Yep allows room for class discussion. All three characters are highly believable and will be easily understood by all readers.
Plot: Overall, the history of this book is very factual and lacks any kind of sugar coating. Readers are presented with mainly facts, sprinkled periodically with Yep’s gift of language in the form of metaphors or similes. Short, concise sentences are used making the novella easy for students to understand. The choppiness of the sentences also eliminates all possibilities of being overwhelmed with details, excess information and unnecessary opinions. Yep did a wonderful job of presenting his story in a way this is relevant to the time period in which this horrific event happened, while maintaining a relevancy that not only stands in present day, but will continue to reach readers in the years to come.
Setting: The setting of this story definitely complements the historical authenticity of the story overall. With Yep’s words, readers are taken back to Hiroshima through mental images created with the details given. Readers are able to create their own ideas of what Hiroshima was like before, during and after the bombing, what it was like inside the plane with the American pilots, and how the Japanese people are still moved by the events of August 6th 1945 today. The time and place are explicitly given to readers through dates.
Theme: The most obvious universal theme and timeless parallels found in this novella would be that war is never the answer. By bringing to light all the personal travesties that occur when countries choose to war with each other and continue to kill their citizens, Yep is enforcing that as humans we should always choose peace over war. This will continue to remain relevant for many years to come.
Style: Yep’s words are limited in number and very direct. Though I am not familiar with much of Yep’s other works I would conclude that this type of writing is conclusive with his personal style and voice. I don’t see much evidence to support that the diction reflects the 1940’s in any way, nor can any connections be made between Yep’s diction and ‘capturing the flavor of the times’. I think the sentences are too compact and direct to make any such observations. Though this story of Hiroshima is entertaining and informational to readers, I wouldn’t describe it as seamless. There is a lot of bouncing back and forth between time periods, characters and setting. The story eventually comes full circle, but does so in a choppy, different kind of way. Realistically, the story could take place in any time period; aside from the dates given, the reader would not explicitly know which time period Yep is referring to.
Additional Criteria: To support authenticity, Yep includes an Afterword for readers to read and a list of sources used to compile his story. This shows readers that Yep spent a significant amount of time researching before writing, and readers can trust his facts to be accurate and true. With the ample facts given, Yep provides a nice balance of fiction by incorporating the two sisters into the historically correct bombing of Hiroshima. Yep’s creation of the sisters is fully explained in the Afterword and readers are given reasons and ideas the characters stemmed from. There is no evidence of stereotyping taking place within this novella.
D. Awards/Recognition and Review Excerpts: Adventuring with Books: A Booklist for PreK-Grade 6, 1997, Booklist Book Review Starts, 1995, Booklist Editors’ Choice: Books for Youth, 1995, Children’s Catalog Eighteenth Edition, 2001, Kaleidoscope: A Multicultural Booklist for Grades K-8 Second Ed. 1997, Middle and Junior High School Library Catalog: Eighth Ed., 2000, Notable Children’s Trade Books in the Field of Social Studies, 1995, Publisher’s Weekly Book Review Stars, 1995, and Sharing Cultures: Asian American Children’s Authors, 2001.
“Yep's clipped, present-tense writing resists editorializing, letting the terrible facts speak for themselves ("Two hundred yards away [from ground zero] people vanish. However, in that instant, their outlines are burnt into the cement like shadows")… this is easy reading-as far as language and sentence structure go-and kids not ready for more comprehensive accounts can here gain a clear and fair introduction to a epoch-defining event.”- Roger Sutton, The Bulletin of the Center for Children’s Books, 1995.
“The account is fair, non-hectoring, and totally devastating. Though accessible to middle-grade readers, this will also interest older readers, who will find nothing condescending in content or format.”- Hazel Rochman, Booklist, 1995.
E. Connections: *Other works by Laurence Yep include: Child of the Owl, Dragon of the Lost Sea, Dragon’s Gate, The Rainbow People, The Dragon Prince, The Lost Garden, The Tiger’s Apprentice, The Magic Paintbrush, The Serpent’s Children, and The Traitor.
*Use this novella to support social studies instruction, activities, and discussions on World War II.
*Have students research the museum dedicated to remembering the lives lost by the dropping of the atomic bomb. Introduce students to the Paper Crane Club and suggest sending in our own paper cranes to be hung on the anniversary of the bombing.

No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.