*Image from indiebound.org
A. Bibliographic Data: Kelly, Jacqueline. The Evolution of Calpurnia Tate. New York: Henry Holt and Company, 2009. ISBN 9780805088410
B. Plot Summary: As Calpurnia Tate can tell you firsthand, there’s a lot to learn when you’re eleven years old. In reading this book, readers will grow right along with Calpurnia (Callie) Tate as she beats the 1899 Texas heat by spending time with nature (and her beloved Grandfather), learning the meaning of unconditional love, finding her own place in her family, and discovering the joys (and many struggles) of being a girl. Jacqueline Kelly is able to illustrate the many discoveries one can find during a lifetime and does so in a historical setting bound to take readers back to a time when things were thought to be simpler. As Callie struggles to balance her love of science with pleasing her Momma (even if that means learning to sew, cook, and clean), she takes us all on a coming of age, turn of the century voyage sure to entertain and educate at the same time.
C. Critical Analysis: Characters: Calpurnia Tate, being the main character, is highly relatable and identifiable to readers. Although the story takes place many years before present-day, readers will be able to relate and understand the complexity of the emotions and feelings Calpurnia encompasses. Boys too can relate to Callie’s struggle to meet expectations, control her strong will, and guide curiosity. I also feel that Calpurnia is very believable- many of the conflicts she meets and resolves are very much alive and present in the lives of students today. Aside from the raw emotion presented in this book, the clothes, dialogue, language and attitudes all reflect and support the late 1800’s era. Examples of this would be in how Callie is asked to wear a bonnet when she’s outside so she won’t get freckles, and referring to a person as a “whip”- a term that would be unfamiliar to students today.
Plot: I feel that the plot of this story is realistic to the time period and that the history is presented accurately versus being sugar coated. Like for women during the 1800’s was hard, and most were expected to manage domestic affairs. Education and science were saved for men, and women were limited in what they could accomplish outside of the home. Because of this, the conflicts and resolutions of this book are very fitting and historically sound. I feel that the typical reader of this book would be between grades 5 and 8. Though the main character is eleven, the complexities of her emotions would seem relevant for older readers as well. Younger readers could understand the novel with the periodic help of a dictionary. I don’t at all feel that the plot is overwhelmed by details, but is presented in a simplistic yet multi-layered manner.
Setting: Jacqueline Kelly does a wonderful job at vividly describing the place in which this story takes place. Through her words, readers are able to picture the Texas nature that steals so much of Callie’s attention. The actual time is not explicitly given, though readers are able to draw conclusions based on Kelly’s descriptions of people and society. Texas has four different physical regions that would be ideal for science explorations and different species of grasshoppers. That being said, I do feel Texas was a great choice for the setting of this book, but do think Kelly could have chosen a different state and been just as successful. I do feel that the recreation done by Kelly fully supports the overall authenticity the book hopes to accomplish.
Theme: Such themes as unconditional love, acceptance, curiosity, freedom and finding one’s self are all apparent in The Evolution of Calpurnia Tate. Though these themes are directly related to the era of the novel, I feel that they would still be relevant to readers today. Everyone has a coming of age moment, and people spend their entire lives searching for unconditional love-with this novel we see the journey of both. I would also describe those themes as universal and timeless, making them likely to remain relevant in the years to come.
Style: The speech patterns and flavor of the time is very well represented through Kelly’s style of writing. She manages to place readers back in time by the way the characters interact with each other, describe occurrences, and responds to situations. This novel is completely seamless and gives the reader a great, easy-flowing novel to read. Because this is Jacqueline Kelly’s first novel, critics have little to compare her personal style to. I can say though that I look forward to reading her future novels and becoming more familiar with her personal writing style.
Additional Criteria: I was a little disappointed to read that Kelly “for the sake of fiction, [has] taken small liberties with Texas history” in her acknowledgement pages located directly after the novel. She further explains “also for the sake of fiction, I have taken liberties with the blooming season of certain plants and the taxonomy of the Vicia genus.” She then apologizes for doing so and continues to acknowledge the various sources she researched to help create her story. By labeling this story as historical fiction, it is scary to see that the author admittedly changes some of the facts to help the fictional story. This tells me that there is not a balance between fact and fiction but that fiction weighs heavier. There was no stereotyping done.
D. Awards/Recognition and Review Excerpts: Cuffies: Children's Booksellers Choose Their Favorite (and not-so-favorite) Books of the Year, 2009 Winner Most Promising New Author, Intermediate-Fiction, John Newbery Medal, 2010 Honor Book, Josette Frank Award, 2010 Winner, Judy Lopez Memorial Award for Children's Literature, 2010, and School Library Journal Battle of the Kids' Books, 2010 Nominee
Amazon Editors' Picks: Top 10 Books, 2009, Amelia Bloomer List, 2010, Best Children's Books of the Year, 2010, Booklist Book Review Stars , 2009, Booklist Editors’ Choice: Books for Youth, 2009, Booklist Top 10 First Novels for Youth, 2009, Booklist Top 10 Historical Fiction for Youth, 2010, Bulletin Blue Ribbons, 2009, Kirkus Book Review Stars, 2009, Notable Children's Books, 2010, Publishers Weekly Best Children's Books, 2009, Publishers Weekly Book Review Stars, 2009, School Library Journal Best Books, 2009,School Library Journal Book Review Stars, 2009, Teachers' Choices, 2010, Washington Post Best Kid's Books, 2009, and YALSA Best Books for Young Adults, 2010
E. Connections: * Have students compare and contrast life in Texas during the 1800’s and now. Students can use a T-chart, ven diagram, or web. Begin and end with a class discussion.
* Read this novel as an extension of the importance of exploration. Where would we be if scientists never explore? What do you think would happen if people stop being curious? How would this affect us?
* Have students reflect through short stories or plays a time when they were expected to do/be something they didn’t quite agree with. How did they situation play out? How did you feel? How did you decide what to do?

No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.