Thursday, September 29, 2011

The True Story of The 3 Little Pigs!


A. Bibliographic Data: Scieszka, Jon. The True Story of the 3 Little Pigs!. New York: Penguin Putnam Books for Young Readers, 1989. ISBN 0670827592

B. Plot Summary: In this very fractured fairytale, A. Wolf, or more commonly known as the big bad wolf, gets to tell his side of the Three Little Pigs story. According to Wolf, the whole story is wrong! What really happens is: a sickly A. Wolf is in the middle of baking his grandmother a birthday cake when he runs out of sugar. In hopes of borrowing a cup of sugar, he travels to his neighbor (First Little Pig)’s house of straw. Since there’s no answer, A. Wolf is about to leave when he sneezes and blows the entire house down. The First Little Pig was already dead, so Wolf felt it would be okay to gobble him up. The same thing happens at the next neighbor (Second Little Pig)’s house of sticks. Finally a very plump A. Wolf travels to the Third Little Pig’s house made of bricks. The Third Little Pig is very rude to A. Wolf and when the cops come, Wolf is in a definite tantrum. A. Wolf ends his story with the simple and comical conclusion that he has most definitely been framed.  

C. Critical Analysis: Characters: Though this book is lacking a strong female character, A. Wolfe wonderfully embodies human traits while maintaining simplicity and relativity. Both good and evil are represented though the reader is getting a different take on a classic fairytale. The wolf was once the evil though he is now being presented as the good in the story. It’s up to the reader to decide! A. Wolf is funny and will be interesting for readers both young and old.

Plot: The plot is simple yet full of action. The conflict of the story, the fact that A. Wolfe is thought to be guilty of a crime he didn’t do, is important to the plot because without it, there would be no variation of the fairytale. Jon Scieszka did a wonderful job of creating a fictional conflict and using it to take a new spin on an old tale. Though there isn’t a resolution to the conflict given (A. Wolf is still in jail) I believe readers will still finish the story feeling satisfied with the ending. It’s entertaining and readers are left with a choice of who to believe and are provided a platform for extension activities.

Setting: The setting in this story is very vague. With the first few pages, the reader is given the feeling that A. Wolf is talking in present-day. He spends some time talking about his side of the story and the unjust label of being big and bad. When he starts to retell the story, we are placed in the past- “Way back in Once Upon a Time time,” where readers now know they’re reading about past events. We bounce back to the future again in the last few pages of the book. This switching back and forth between the present and past allows readers to know more about A. Wolf.  Readers know how A. Wolf is doing today and are able to see his role (in his own words) in the classic Three Little Pigs story.

Theme: I’m not sure there is a theme to this story though readers can loosely draw the conclusion that there is always two sides to every story. In the case of A. Wolf it is a very comical, silly side to the story but it’s worthy of being told none the less.

Style: Jon Scieszka does a wonderful job of bringing the sound of spoken language to print. When reading the story (either silently or aloud) the reader immediately feels the expressions A. Wolf must have had when saying the words. It’s great! Though this is a fractured fairytale, there are elements of the original tale embedded within the story. References are made to the pig’s chinny chin chin, the houses are made of the same materials, A. Wolf does in fact blow the houses down, and in the end the Third Pig still goes uneaten. The rhythm of the story is easy on the reader and listener and again, reiterates the sound of spoken language.

Illustrations: The illustrations in this book are one of a kind and highly identifiable. They complement the story beautifully and allow the perfect accent to the comical text (by adding their own additional funny details). I feel that the overall style of the story is matched well with the pictures, while the pacing, mood and design comes together to make one complete piece of art.

Cultural Markers: I feel that the language is a true reflection of our culture. The pictures have a little more fantastical feel to them, but can still be found as somewhat realistic. I wouldn’t say readers would gain any specific insight into the American culture by reading this book but they will become familiar with the characters in one of our most popular fairytales.

Anthologies: With the inclusion of elements from The Three Little Pigs, I would say young readers will be very familiar with this story. Background knowledge is always a good thing to have and build upon, especially with early readers. I would vote for this book to be read aloud to students by an adult. With the primary grades doing the most studies on fairytales, the actual text might be too advanced for them with this particular variation.

D. Awards/Recognitions and Review Excerpts: Golden Sower Award winner in 1992 and a Parents’ Choice Award winner in 1996.
A Notable Children’s Book of 1990, selected by Children’s Catalog as a Best Book in 2006, and a Children’s Book Council ‘Not Just for Children Anymore!’ Best Book of 2000.
“Scieszka and his comic cohort, Smith, ignited a resurgence of retellings and brought new vision to fairy tales with True Story of the Three Little Pigs. Below Scieszka's patina of humor and playfulness, there is a respect for kids that shapes his work. His books may appeal to adults, but they primarily are created for, motivated by, and support the vision of kids”. –Susie Wilde, Children’s Literature

E. Connections: * Readers can come up with their own fractured fairytale from a different character’s perspective. Any one of the Three Pigs for example
* This can be used as an introduction to a government lesson on fair trial procedures. Students could then act out the trial of A. Wolf based on this story.
* Have students compare and contrast the original Three Little Pigs story and Jon Scieszka’s story.

*Image from Amazon.com

There Was an Old Lady Who Swallowed a Fly


A. Bibliographic Data: Taback, Simms. There Was an Old Lady Who Swallowed a Fly. New York: Penguin Books, 1997. ISBN 0670869392

B. Plot Summary: In this classic, well-known poem turned book, an old lady begins the story by swallowing a fly. In order to catch the fly, she ends up swallowing a spider, then a bird, followed by a cat, a dog, a cow, and finally a horse. In the end the old lady dies…of course.

C. Critical Analysis: Characters: You can definitely describe this main character as a strong female… she does some outstanding things! Though there is no dialogue and no other solid characters besides the old lady, the story has a fullness to it and sense of completion. The old lady is not complicated or dynamic but simple and easily relatable to readers of all ages. Forces of good and evil are not explicitly defined.

Plot: This story is full of action! It is fast paced and the old lady seems to barely have time to breathe! The plot itself is simple with a conflict presented in the first page and consequent actions follow in hopes of fixing the conflict. The conflict is crucial to the plot as it sets the foundation for the entire poem to take place. In the end, the conflict is resolved in a realistic and plausible way… of course.

Setting: The setting of this story is very vague; ultimately it could take place anywhere, at any time. Time does seem to pass quickly, and this helps us understand the protagonist by creating a sense of urgency in her quest to solve the problem.

Theme: The theme of this poem is a little shaky. Very literally speaking, it could be interpreted to mean do not eat bugs. More metaphorically speaking though, I think you can tie this poem to the idea that what may start out as a small problem can end up as a huge problem before you know it. I also think there’s some underlying message of: don’t keep doing the same thing (swallowing a living animal) to fix a problem…try something new! J Taback even includes his own moral of the story at the end of the poem: “Never swallow a horse.”(29).

Style: There is a great sense of rhythm created with this poem, and would be great for reading aloud. The repetition provides students with opportunities to join in, and will keep them fully engaged with the text throughout its entirety. Though the original author of this poem is unknown, it captures the sound of spoken language in print very effectively. Taback does a wonderful job of sticking to the original text of the poem but adding in his own comical flair through additional character’s comments in the story, making this rendition his own.

Illustrations: These illustrations truly make the story! Without them, it would be just another retelling of the ancient poem for children to listen to again. By using “an ever-expanding die-cut hole” Taback presented readers with a funny, new, exciting way to actually see what the old lady swallowed! Without a doubt, these illustrations complement the story extremely well. They also help create the mood and pacing for the story.

Cultural Markers: According to Taback, this poem has been around in the United States since the 1940’s. With that in mind, I think this story does a great job of reflecting our culture. The language used is still relevant today, and the images used would be entertaining to readers of the past, present, and future.

Anthologies: This story has the potential of being very familiar to readers. Since it has been around for such a long time, many students will have heard it before entering school for the first time. As metioned before, Taback provides the reader with a few lines of background information about the poem on the last page of the book. This book would be ideal for both children and adults to read.

D. Awards/Recognitions: New York Times Best Illustrated Book of the Year winner 1997, Randolph Caldecott Medal winner 1998, and Society of School Librarians International Book Award 1998.
One of the Best Children’s Books of the Year in 1998, one of Capitol Choices in 1997, chosen by Children’s Catalog in 2001 and 2006, one of Los Angeles’ 100 Best Books of 1997, one of the Notable Children’s Books of 1998, a Publisher’s Weekly Book Review Star, August 1997, Reading Magic Award winner 1997, Recommended Literature K-12 2002, a School Library Journal Book Review Star December 1997.

E. Connections: *Students can create their own ‘There Was an Old Lady’ stories using animals of their choice
*This book can be used as an introduction to a science lesson on food chains
* Other books by Simms Taback (he’s written over 40) include: Joseph Had a Little Overcoat and This is the House that Jack Built.

*Image from Amazon.com

Raccoon's Last Race

A. Bibliograhic Data: Bruchac, Joseph and James Bruchac. Raccoon’s Last Race. New York: Dial Books for Young Readers, 2004. ISBN 0803729774

B. Plot Summary: This traditional Abenaki story presents readers with the ‘real’ reason raccoons have short legs and a stocky body. The story begins with a very different looking Raccoon named Azban (he has longer legs and a taller, leaner body) that prides himself as being the fastest of all the animals. He is constantly looking for ways to trick the other animals into racing him (since he is so confident he’ll win) and teases and taunts the other animals when they do agree to race. Because of his mischief, the other animals begin to stay away from Azban the raccoon. One day Azban comes across a new person to race- a rock sitting on top of a hill. Against the rock’s protests Azban pushes the rock down the hill and tries to race him! As the rock is unable to stop (since he’s not used to traveling) Azban ends up smashed flat and wide. After all the other animals refuse to help Azban, he turns to an ant and makes a promise to be the ant’s friend if he gathers all the other ants to help pull Azban back into shape. The ant agrees and as the ants work together to pull Azban together, Azban becomes impatient and shakes the ants off of him as soon as he is able to. Azban breaks his promise to the ants and as a result he is left to be “the short, squatty animal he is to this day” (27).

C. Critical Analysis: Characters: The archetype of good can be seen through the ants’ willingness to help Azban and their ability to work together to accomplish a common goal. Evil can be seen in the way Azban treated the other animals in the beginning of the story (teasing, taunting, tricking etc.), his arrogance and need to beat others, and his failure to keep his promise to the ants. In the end, this was the last straw that solidified Azban’s fate to be a slow animal with short legs from then on. The characters also obtain human traits such as speaking, feeling emotions, and the ability to reason throughout the situations in the book. Azban the Raccoon, the other animals briefly mentioned (Bear, Fox and Rabbit), Grandfather Rock, and the ants are all simple characters that complement the story’s underlining message without overcomplicating.

Plot: I would definitely describe the plot of this story as simple. There is action in all parts-beginning, middle and end that will leave the reader satisfied and engaged throughout the book. The primary conflict in the story- Azban needs help from the other animals he was once so mean to, fits in well with the overall plot. The conclusion is plausible and not too over the top. The reader will not be surprised to hear that Azban was too impatient to wait for the ants to finish their work, leaving him with a different body. Typical Azban!

Setting: The setting is apparent through the illustrations and the characters. The reader will be able to assume where the story is taking place by the types of animals named. While the time is unknown, it does seem to pass quickly. Bruchac is able to set readers up with the idea of a distant past by stating “long ago…” in the first sentence and brings them up to date in the last sentences with “to this day”.

Theme: This story is centered around teaching readers not to be boastful and always keep their promises. This idea can be applied to readers everywhere across the globe, and can be used to model the incorrect way to treat others. Although good doesn’t explicitly triumph over evil, readers can see that Azban gets what he deserves for breaking his promises and constantly teasing the other animals. I would definitely describe this story as ethical because it addresses right and wrong while allowing readers to decide for themselves if the actions in this story are acceptable.

Style: This story is sprinkled with repetition and rhythm. This will encourage readers to join in while listening and allow room for them to make predictions. The dialogue in the story is reflective of the Abenaki language and can be seen as different from English. Readers will be able to pick up on that through the length of the sentences and the words used. In the author’s note Bruchac explains that stories were often used to discuss bad behavior instead of punishment. In that sense, I would say this story is cultural specific because it directly meets the needs of the Abenaki tribe.

Illustrations: The illustrations in this book complement the story’s flow, pacing, and movement very well. They are colorful and eye-catching yet simple and do not take away from the actual text of the story. The details of the illustration are beautifully done and readers will be drawn to them to get a better feel for the character’s personalities. Arguego and Dewey did a great job of reflecting the author’s words through their pictures.

Cultural Markers: This story helps readers gain insight to the Abenaki culture by understanding their dependence on stories. The story places emphasis on how you treat others, not being boastful and keeping promises, which also lets readers know that members of the Abenaki tribe take pride in those things. I feel that the text and illustrations are true reflections of the culture and also gives readers an impression of the culture.

Anthologies: The two authors provide readers with background knowledge before the story begins. This would be great to read to students along with the story itself. This book would be great for children to read on their own, or for adults to read a loud to the students.

D. Awards/Recognition and Review Excerpts: One of the Children’s Catalog’s Best Books in 2006 (Nineteenth Edition), Storytelling World Award winner, 2006.
“In this lively retelling of an Abenaki pourquoi trickster tale, Azban the Raccoon gets what he deserves.”- Ken Marantz and Sylvia Marantz, Children’s Literature
“Azban the Raccoon is a favorite Abenaki trickster and this father-and-son storytelling pair creates a lively, clever, and authentic version of his story.”- Kirkus Reviews, October 2004

E. Connections: *Other titles by the same two authors and same two illustrators include: Turtle’s Race with Beaver and How Chipmunk Got His Stripes.
*Have a student-led discussion in which they discuss the importance of keeping promises, how it feels to be let down, and how it feels to be around a boastful person
* With the amount of action in the story and the sounds of the text, this would be great for Reader’s Theatre

*Image from amazon.com

Wednesday, September 14, 2011

Kitten's First Full Moon


A. Bibliographic Data: Henkes, Kevin. Kitten’s First Full Moon. New York: Greenwillow Books, 2004. ISBN 0060588292
B. Plot Summary: Kitten can’t wait to get her paws on the big bowl of milk in the sky (i.e. the full moon) that seems to be waiting just for her. She does everything she can to reach it including stretching, jumping, chasing, climbing and swimming. She can’t quite seem to reach the moon though so she returns home sad, tired and very wet. Luckily, upon arriving back to her front steps she sees an actual bowl of milk that really is waiting just for her.
C. Critical Analysis: Characters: There is only one character in this book and that’s Kitten. She has no speaking parts in the story so the reader relies heavily on the pictures to gain insight to her character. Kevin Henkes does a great job of bringing kitten to life through facial expressions, movement and action. Young readers will find Kitten to be relatable as she possesses some human characteristics (though she’s lacking the most common-the ability to speak) such as determination, curiosity, and persistence. The audience will also find Kitten to be interesting and even funny. With Kitten, Kevin Henkes has definitely provided a unique way for looking at the sky sure to stick with even the youngest of readers!
Plot: This conflict can be applied to readers of all ages, at all different stages in life. Surely we have all wanted something so bad and tried our hardest only to be unsuccessful. But just like in this story, we shouldn’t feel discouraged because low and behold, there can always be a slight change in luck. In Kitten’s case she was lucky enough to return home to a full bowl of milk ready for drinking. This solution clearly satisfies the conflict and will be acceptable to readers while providing one of those never ending teachable moments for parents, teachers and librarians. The illustrations in this book undoubtedly help move the story along by providing direct reflections of the words. The conflict and resolution are well represented!  
Setting: Taken from the illustrations, it is clear to see that the story takes place at night, outside, around the home of Kitten. Although time isn’t explicitly defined, readers will know that the moon comes out at night-therefor Kitten is on the hunt at night! In this case, I think the setting plays the most important role with this story than the other two books I’ve reviewed. It adds to the story overall and gives the reader even more reason to feel for Kitten! She’s all alone at night! Furthermore, I do feel that this story could be metaphorically applied to all aspects of life. An unattainable want, a dark night and a struggling Kitten…you’ve got a foundation for a whole different kind of book.
Theme: As mentioned before, this book’s theme can be important to all ages. I love that Kitten has curiosity (a trait most young readers will undoubtedly have) and the determination to keep trying to reach her bowl of milk in the sky. This can be used as an example to show students that they should stay determined on accomplishing goals. When Kitten returns home wet and tired, she finds her bowl of milk right there waiting for her! This is great to show readers to stay positive and not to ever completely rule out luck. Both of these themes are meaningful and delicately presented to readers. Henkes does not seem to be pushy or preaching to readers.  Instead he created a highly applicable story that can be enjoyed by everyone!
Style: Kevin Henkes uses repetition in two different instances. “Poor Kitten!” is repeated after something happens to Kitten while on her adventure and “Still, there was the little bowl of milk, just waiting.” is repeated after Kitten’s failed attempts to reach the milk. This provides the readers with predictability and allows readers to join in while the story is being read. Other style devices and sound features Henkes uses include: imagery, onomatopoeias, and rhythm.   
Illustrations: Although most of Kevin Henke’s other works contain bright, vibrant colors, Kitten’s First Full Moon does not. Instead, the drawings of this book are done with shades of black, gray and white. The title page lets us know that Henkes used colored pencils and gouache to complete the illustrations. Although some of the illustrations are fairly detailed, overall they encompass a sense of simplicity that flows well with the level of text in the book. Readers are given pictures that strongly complement the story while creating the feeling of night and the unexpected. The mood and pacing of the book are also established by the illustrations ranging from full page illustrations to smaller, less than one fourth of the page pictures of Kitten.
Cultural Markers: With this story, culture does not override the plot. Instead, because Henkes chose the main character to be a Kitten, she can relate to all readers regardless of ethnicity or race. Simultaneously, with an animal for a main character readers will not be offended in any way. And although Kitten is a girl, she has no particular girl-like actions that would make her completely different from male readers.   
D. Awards/Recognition and Review Excerpts: Book Sense Book of the Year winner, 2005, Books of the Year Ages 2-4 winner, 2004, Borders Original Voices finalist, 2004, Charlotte Zolotow Award winner, 2005, Elizabeth Burr/Worzalla Award winner, 2005, New York Times Best Illustrated Children’s Books of the Year winner, 2004, Parents Choice Award winner, 2004, Randolph Caldecott Medal winner, 2005, and White Ravens Award winner, 2005.  “This gentle picture book feels transported from an earlier era. Reminiscent of the writing of Margaret Wise Brown, its deceptively simple language and masterful pacing transcend time. Lucky Reader!” –CCBC (Cooperative Children’s Book Center Choices 2005.
E. Connections:  * This can be used as an introductory story to a math lesson on circles or a science lesson on the cycles of the moon
* Students can act out the story by moving the way Kitten does on her quest for the moon
* As a class, think of other shapes that can be found in our natural world. What might animals confuse them for?

Millions of Cats


A. Bibliographic Data: Gag, Wanda. Millions of Cats. New York: The Putnam & Grosset Group, 1996. ISBN 0698113632
B. Plot Summary: To appease his wife’s loneliness, an old man sets out to find his wife a kitten. He travels far and finally comes to a hill covered with kittens. He begins to search for the prettiest kitten to bring home but quickly realizes he isn’t able to leave any of the kittens behind! Upon returning home, the old man and his wife are faced with the problem of feeding these millions of cats so they turn to the kittens for help. The old man asks the kittens to decide who is the prettiest kitten of all, but ends up with chaos instead of answers. After the chaos dies down, the old man and his wife discover a tiny, humble kitten that they love and nourish. In the end, they are confident they have the prettiest kitten in the world!
C. Critical Analysis: Characters: The characters in this book have certain qualities that make them relatable to readers of all ages. Loneliness, indecisiveness, and love can be found in Wanda Gag’s characters along with opportunities to grow and look past outer beauty. Even the earliest of readers can relate to feeling lonely or not being able to make up his/her mind! The old man and his wife are brought to life through pictures and dialogue, encouraging readers to make connections with them. Although the cats have a small speaking part in the story, they are still noteworthy. The entire moral of the story rests in the one to two lines said by the tiny kitten!
Plot: This story is very logically put together. The story began with a problem, presented a solution but made another problem simultaneously, and finally gave a conclusion which satisfied all conflicts. The plot is interesting yet leaves some room for predictability which is important to enhance young readers’ comprehension. The audience will find this book’s conflict to be interesting and the solution to be acceptable. The illustrations help move the plot along by creating a consistent setting and supporting shifts made by the different conflicts.
Setting: The setting is acceptable and relevant to the text. The first illustration in the book gives readers an immediate idea of where the story is taking place. There is no emphasis placed on time though the reader can take in the illustrations to assume that the story took place years ago.  The setting is also presented to readers through Gag’s words. She describes the house in which the old man and his wife live, giving readers the opportunity to picture the house for themselves before looking at the illustration.
Theme: The deeper meaning of this story comes in the last few pages of the book. Once the old man asks the kittens “Which one of you is the prettiest?” the answering kittens scream variations of “I am!” and eventually begin to fight. After the fighting dies down, a single kitten is discovered and states “…when you asked who was the prettiest, I didn’t say anything. So nobody bothered about me”. This allowed the kitten to survive the fighting and live happily ever after with the old man and his wife. This teaches readers that it isn’t okay to brag and be overly boastful. Instead, humbleness and humility are important characteristics to have. In my opinion, this is a very meaningful lesson for readers and Gag presents it beautifully without being overbearing or preachy.
Style: Wanda Gag uses some specific features of sound such as rhythm and repetition. There is one sentence she chooses to repeat in the book which provides a distinct rhythm while reading the story aloud. Though the sentence in its entirety is only repeated twice, words from the sentence (hundreds, thousands, millions and billions and trillions of cats) are continuously repeated. This will encourage students to join in while listening! Another aspect of Gag’s writing I noticed comes from her word choice. Having looked to see when the book was originally published (1928) it made sense for the dialogue to seem a little less current. Nonetheless, it was a nice change of pace and this book was beautifully written.
Illustrations: The illustrations in this book are wonderfully done and different than any illustrations I’ve recently seen. There is not a single color used on any of the pages only pure black and white drawings (not even a shade of gray can be found). Don’t let the lack of color fool you though, these illustrations are very complex and intricately done. Pictures sometimes spread across two pages or can be contained to a single page within this book, giving the reader a path to follow along while reading. In my opinion, this complements the overall flow, design and quality of the book very nicely.
Cultural Markers: There is little having to do with culture in this book. The old man and his wife appear to be Caucasian though nothing is said about their actual ethnicity. The reader can draw conclusions about the people during this time through certain aspects of the main characters. For example, the old man walks to find the kittens instead of driving a car or flying in an airplane, the old woman wears a bonnet and a long dress giving readers an idea of how women dressed during this time, and lastly, the house on the first page shows a little about how and where people lived during this time. This book would not be found offensive by any gender, race or ethnicity and would be an asset to any library!
D. Awards/Recognition and Review Excerpts: A John Newbery Medal winner, 1929, and a Lewis Carroll Shelf Award winner, 1958. “A perennial favorite.”-The New York Times, “A favorite for so many years.” –Parent’s Choice, and “An outstanding example of a book in which text and illustrations seem to flow together.” –Children’s Literature
E. Connections: *Could be used to begin an early math lesson on large numbers
* Have a student-led discussion on alternate endings for the book
* Other popular books by Wanda Gag include: ABC Bunny, The Funny Thing, and Snippy and Snappy.   
*Picture from barnesandnoble.com

There Is a Bird on Your Head!



A. Bibliographic Data: Willems, Mo. There is a Bird on Your Head!. New York: Hyperion Books for Children, 2007. ISBN 9781423106869
B. Plot Summary: In this concise yet very entertaining picture book, an elephant and a “piggie” are minding their own business when a bird lands on the elephant’s head. One bird turns into two, two birds turn into a nest, and a nest turns into three eggs (and eventually three chicks) and one grumpy elephant. Through simple and comical conversation, elephant and piggie solve elephant’s predicament only to end the book with a slightly different, yet still comical, problem. 
C. Critical Analysis: Characters: Mo Willems’ characters are simple yet relatable. Most readers will be familiar with an elephant and pig, giving them background knowledge for approaching this book. The character’s humor is projected through words and pictures by utilizing punctuation, facial expressions, body language, movement, and gestures. The pictures truly bring elephant and piggie to life- the reader can really SEE how they’re feeling! Although elephants and pigs don’t talk in real life, these characters are still consistent with the targeted audience (beginning readers). As with most cartoons and fiction designed for this audience group, animals often possess humanlike tendencies.  
Plot: The plot of this book is also very simple. The consistency of having only two characters with little else on the pages besides their dialogue gives the book an easy flowing feel. The conflict of the story-the bird landing on elephant’s head is believable and possible especially to young readers full of imagination. Though adult readers may have their doubts, the conflict is not so distracting to take away from the overall story. The outcome, or resolution, is comical and believable as well. Again the simple yet highly relevant illustrations help move the story along by giving a direct reflection of the dialogue between characters.
Setting: Mo Wilems does not give the reader an outside setting. Behind the illustrations of the characters, there is a blank white page void of any clues as to where the story is actually taking place. Willems does not place any emphasis on time either. Instead the focus is solely on the characters and their conversation. Universally, this story could take place anywhere though some conclusions can be drawn based on the plot. Birds fly outside so it would be okay to assume that this story does in fact take place outside though it is never explicitly explained. Readers are left with the freedom to create their own setting. This could be a great extension activity to give students a better understanding of how a certain setting can affect a story.  
Theme: In looking at the theme of the book it is yet again a simple but important one. In solving the problem of the birds on his head, elephant is given the great idea to simply ask the birds to go away and the birds immediately agree to relocate. This is reiterating that questions are important and it will never hurt to ask. This is a meaningful lesson to both kids and adults as sometimes even the simplest of conclusions to a problem can go overlooked!
Style: Willems utilizes different features of sound such as onomatopoeia. Though the words used are simple, emotions can still be felt by the reader through the use of all capital letters, ending punctuation and of course, the illustrations. There is a consistent back and forth balance between elephant and piggie that portrays a sense of rhythm though there are no rhyming words or an actual beat to the story. Willems’ humor can also be seen through his style of writing, making this short read enjoyable for readers of all ages.
Illustrations: The illustrations absolutely complement the story. They are simple and not over the top while achieving and undeniable sense of expressiveness. The illustrations do a great job at adhering to the pacing of the story- one character on each page to complement the back and forth dialogue. Elephant and piggie’s  facial expressions throughout the book leave little for the imagination. You know exactly what they’re feeling! The illustrations are done with pastel like colors, and appear to have been created with pencils rather than paint. By not using bright, vivid colors, Willems further supported the understated, simple feel of the story.
Cultural Markers: Because Willems chose to use animals, no culture is represented making the characters relatable to anyone regardless of gender, race or ethnicity. While technically this book doesn’t support multiculturalism in the classroom, it doesn’t discriminate either. This would be a great addition to any beginning reader’s library.
D. Awards/Recognition and Review Excerpt: Charlotte Award winner, 2010 and a Theodor Seuss Geisel Award winner, 2008. “New readers are likely to find reading this book an engaging way to show how punctuation can change the meaning; the expressions on the faces will make it easy for them to know just how to read with expressions as well” Mary Hynes-Berry, Hyperion’s Books for Children, 2007.
E. Connections: * This is one of the many Elephant & Piggie Books written and illustrated by Mo Willems. Students can use the series as a basis for an author study.
*Because of the direct use of dialogue, this book would be great for reader’s theatre.
*Use this book as an introduction to a behavioral lesson on the importance of using words to solve problems and asking questions.
-Image from BooksofWonder.com