A. Bibliographic Data: Scieszka, Jon. The True Story of the 3 Little Pigs!. New York: Penguin Putnam Books for Young Readers, 1989. ISBN 0670827592
B. Plot Summary: In this very fractured fairytale, A. Wolf, or more commonly known as the big bad wolf, gets to tell his side of the Three Little Pigs story. According to Wolf, the whole story is wrong! What really happens is: a sickly A. Wolf is in the middle of baking his grandmother a birthday cake when he runs out of sugar. In hopes of borrowing a cup of sugar, he travels to his neighbor (First Little Pig)’s house of straw. Since there’s no answer, A. Wolf is about to leave when he sneezes and blows the entire house down. The First Little Pig was already dead, so Wolf felt it would be okay to gobble him up. The same thing happens at the next neighbor (Second Little Pig)’s house of sticks. Finally a very plump A. Wolf travels to the Third Little Pig’s house made of bricks. The Third Little Pig is very rude to A. Wolf and when the cops come, Wolf is in a definite tantrum. A. Wolf ends his story with the simple and comical conclusion that he has most definitely been framed.
C. Critical Analysis: Characters: Though this book is lacking a strong female character, A. Wolfe wonderfully embodies human traits while maintaining simplicity and relativity. Both good and evil are represented though the reader is getting a different take on a classic fairytale. The wolf was once the evil though he is now being presented as the good in the story. It’s up to the reader to decide! A. Wolf is funny and will be interesting for readers both young and old.
Plot: The plot is simple yet full of action. The conflict of the story, the fact that A. Wolfe is thought to be guilty of a crime he didn’t do, is important to the plot because without it, there would be no variation of the fairytale. Jon Scieszka did a wonderful job of creating a fictional conflict and using it to take a new spin on an old tale. Though there isn’t a resolution to the conflict given (A. Wolf is still in jail) I believe readers will still finish the story feeling satisfied with the ending. It’s entertaining and readers are left with a choice of who to believe and are provided a platform for extension activities.
Setting: The setting in this story is very vague. With the first few pages, the reader is given the feeling that A. Wolf is talking in present-day. He spends some time talking about his side of the story and the unjust label of being big and bad. When he starts to retell the story, we are placed in the past- “Way back in Once Upon a Time time,” where readers now know they’re reading about past events. We bounce back to the future again in the last few pages of the book. This switching back and forth between the present and past allows readers to know more about A. Wolf. Readers know how A. Wolf is doing today and are able to see his role (in his own words) in the classic Three Little Pigs story.
Theme: I’m not sure there is a theme to this story though readers can loosely draw the conclusion that there is always two sides to every story. In the case of A. Wolf it is a very comical, silly side to the story but it’s worthy of being told none the less.
Style: Jon Scieszka does a wonderful job of bringing the sound of spoken language to print. When reading the story (either silently or aloud) the reader immediately feels the expressions A. Wolf must have had when saying the words. It’s great! Though this is a fractured fairytale, there are elements of the original tale embedded within the story. References are made to the pig’s chinny chin chin, the houses are made of the same materials, A. Wolf does in fact blow the houses down, and in the end the Third Pig still goes uneaten. The rhythm of the story is easy on the reader and listener and again, reiterates the sound of spoken language.
Illustrations: The illustrations in this book are one of a kind and highly identifiable. They complement the story beautifully and allow the perfect accent to the comical text (by adding their own additional funny details). I feel that the overall style of the story is matched well with the pictures, while the pacing, mood and design comes together to make one complete piece of art.
Cultural Markers: I feel that the language is a true reflection of our culture. The pictures have a little more fantastical feel to them, but can still be found as somewhat realistic. I wouldn’t say readers would gain any specific insight into the American culture by reading this book but they will become familiar with the characters in one of our most popular fairytales.
Anthologies: With the inclusion of elements from The Three Little Pigs, I would say young readers will be very familiar with this story. Background knowledge is always a good thing to have and build upon, especially with early readers. I would vote for this book to be read aloud to students by an adult. With the primary grades doing the most studies on fairytales, the actual text might be too advanced for them with this particular variation.
D. Awards/Recognitions and Review Excerpts: Golden Sower Award winner in 1992 and a Parents’ Choice Award winner in 1996.
A Notable Children’s Book of 1990, selected by Children’s Catalog as a Best Book in 2006, and a Children’s Book Council ‘Not Just for Children Anymore!’ Best Book of 2000.
“Scieszka and his comic cohort, Smith, ignited a resurgence of retellings and brought new vision to fairy tales with True Story of the Three Little Pigs. Below Scieszka's patina of humor and playfulness, there is a respect for kids that shapes his work. His books may appeal to adults, but they primarily are created for, motivated by, and support the vision of kids”. –Susie Wilde, Children’s Literature
E. Connections: * Readers can come up with their own fractured fairytale from a different character’s perspective. Any one of the Three Pigs for example
* This can be used as an introduction to a government lesson on fair trial procedures. Students could then act out the trial of A. Wolf based on this story.
* Have students compare and contrast the original Three Little Pigs story and Jon Scieszka’s story.
*Image from Amazon.com

No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.