A. Bibliographic Data: Engle, Margarita. The Surrender Tree: Poems of Cuba’s Struggle for Freedom. New York: Henry Holt and Company, 2008. ISBN 9780805086744
B. Plot Summary: In this collection of poems, Margarita Engle provides readers with a look inside the struggle for freedom Cuba faced over the span of close to one hundred years. The main character, Rosa, is a young girl with the blessing and curse of knowing how to heal people with the use of plants. Though she strives to help everyone, her efforts can’t erase the years of heartache and prejudice that call Cuba home. This is a collection of beautifully written poems that not only define a country but an entire race as well.
C. Critical Analysis: Rhythm: Engle achieves a distinct rhythm with her poems that directly aide in the overall meaning of the poem. Most of the poems consist of more than one verse providing readers with a break in their reading. This break often signifies a change in thought, emotion or subject. With Rosa expressing herself so freely in a given poem, the meter and rhythm of the poems help readers to keep up and stay focused.
Rhyme: Engle does not use rhyming words or matching sounds in this collection. Instead, the narration is completed in free verse and gives the reader a complete insight into Rosa’s world. I feel that the use of rhyme would have inhibited Engle from completely portraying Rosa and her other characters. I also think the tempo and message of the collection would have been distracted if sing-song matching words would have been incorporated. Though I typically enjoy rhyming poems, I feel that this particular poem’s purpose and message was clearer without rhyming words.
Sound: Engle uses alliteration throughout her poems along with careful consideration for the words and sounds she chooses to incorporate. The poems are easy on the ears and have a beautiful sound and would work well as a piece to be acted out in reader’s theatre. Because this is such a close topic to Engle’s heart, I feel that the words she chose to use create a serious yet light read for students learning about this country.
Language: Similes, metaphors and personification can be found throughout this work as Engle uses a variety of techniques to enhance the book’s language. The arrangement of the words and phrases does a wonderful job at adding emphasis to the already effective language, giving the reader even more insight into the author’s message.
Imagery: Through the vivid sensory words, readers are given endless visual images while reading these poems. I would describe the images as surprising in their ability to be delicate in a collection depicting the struggle of an entire people. These images and their ability to reach the reader are closely related and dependent on Engle’s unique language choices.
Emotions: In creating a work that is so close to her heart, Engle was sure to produce some serious emotion through this collection. Though the message and topic is serious and full of injustices, Engle manages to create opportunities for light and sweetness to shine through. The reader will pass through a slew of emotions while reading this collection including sadness, anger, and tenderness. All of these feelings are very natural and are exactly what Engle hoped her readers would feel. No matter the color of your skin, the age, or the gender, I feel that all readers will be moved by this work.
Poetry Books: Overall, I think the balance and organization of the poems was very effective. Since there are no illustrations in this book, readers are relying on their own imaginations to create pictures of the text. The book may appear to be long but in reality is just the right amount of text for a wide variety of readers. I would describe this book as having both current and future appeal to readers and should be included in classroom libraries (if for no other reason to support multiculturism). There is ample information provided by Engle that supports readers’ background information- her personal connection, a timeline of historical events, references, and historical notes. These will be great additions to any reading done in the classroom or library.
D. Awards/Recognition and Review Excerpts: Amelia Boomer List 2009, Booklist Best Books for Young Adults 2009, Booklist Book Review Stars 2008, Booklist Editors' Choice: Books for Youth 2008, Choices 2009, Middle and Junior High School Library Catalog Ninth Edition Supplement 2008, Notable Children’s Books 2009, Notable Social Studies Trade Books for Young People 2009, Pure Poetry 2008, Senior High Core Collection Supplement to the Seventh Edition 2008, YALSA Best Books for Young Adults 2009.
Americas Award for Children's and Young Adult Literature 2009, Claudia Lewis Award winner 2009, Cybil Award winner 2008, Jane Addams Children's Book Award winner 2009, John Newbery Medal 2009, Lee Bennett Hopkins Poetry Award winner 2009, Pura Belpre Award winner 2009
“Tales of political dissent can prove, at times, to be challenging reads for youngsters, but this fictionalized version of the Cuban struggle for independence from Spain may act as an entry to the form.”- Kirkus, Kirkus Reviews March 2008
“It will be a great choice to hand to reluctant readers or to history students to humanize a lesson about Hispanic heritage or the Spanish American War.”- Stephanie Petruso, VOYA June 2008
E. Connections: *Other works by Margarita Engle include: The Poet Slave of Cuba, Tropical Secrets, The Firefly Letters, and most recently Hurricane Dancers, the First Caribbean Pirate Shipwreck
* Hold a class discussion in which feelings, emotions and thoughts portrayed in The Surrender Tree are identified and discussed
*Complete character analysis on the various characters in the book- Rosa, Lieutenant Death, Jose, and Silvia.
*Image from guanabee.com

No comments:
Post a Comment
Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.